By Bill Whitehouse

'What's unsuitable With what is correct' is a critique of Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf's e-book: what is correct With Islam. all through his e-book, Imam Rauf seeks to attract parallels among, at the one hand, constitutional democracy within the usa and, nevertheless, the character of Islam.

He seeks to argue that they either percentage an analogous method of rules akin to: rights, freedom, function, and morality. in spite of the fact that, he usually does the foregoing in tricky methods either with appreciate to his explication in regards to the nature of democracy, in addition to when it comes to his clarification of Islam.

Unfortuantely, Imam Rauf stumbles into very risky territory whilst he seeks to place forth a controversy which keeps that simply because either democracy (through the idea of inalienable rights which are endowed to us by means of our author) and Islam (through the information of revelation and the Prophetic culture) are rooted in Divine authority, then, somebody is lower than a duty to stick with or obey no matter what leaders are in strength (within a democracy and/or an Islamic nation) only if such leaders act according to the foundations and values proven via Divinity.

However, Imam Rauf fails to convincingly reveal -- both with admire to democracy or Islam -- why somebody should still settle for his interpretation of both democracy or Islam. consequently, Imam Rauf adopts a number of positions relating: 9-11, agencies, the Iraq/Afghanistan wars, banks, international coverage, capitalism, the announcement of Independence, the structure, The invoice of Rights, Islam, shari'ah (so-called Islamic law), and the Sufi course that won't be tenable.

Imam Rauf is anyone who's one of many leaders of the gang of people who're on the middle of the hurricane surrounding the proposed group heart (also referred to as Cordoba condominium, Park51, and the floor 0 mosque) in manhattan urban. Given his centrality in that controversy, the method of seriously exploring Imam Rauf's standpoint referring to quite a few matters can be of price to either Muslims and non-Muslims.

The indisputable fact that 3 years after Sep 11 Imam Rauf wrote a booklet -- specifically, 'What's correct With Islam' -- when it comes to a few of the aforementioned concerns -- bargains a chance to have interaction what he has to assert and examine such concerns. the truth that many folks -- either Muslim and non-Muslim -- have counseled Imam Rauf's e-book increases a few vital questions relating such endorsements -- specifically if the severe statement in 'What's fallacious With what is correct' constitutes a correct and reasonable serious overview of Imam Rauf's ideas.

Show description

Read Online or Download What's Wrong With What's Right -- A Critique of Imam Feisal Rauf's Book: What's Right With Islam PDF

Similar islam books

The Teaching and Study of Islam in Western Universities (Islamic Studies Series)

Public curiosity within the faith of Islam and in Muslim groups in recent times has generated an impetus for Western Universities to set up an array of Institutes and courses devoted to the research of Islam. regardless of the expansion in variety of courses devoted to this learn, little or no realization has been paid to the proper form of such courses and the assumptions that should underlie this sort of learn.

The Jihad of Jesus: The Sacred Nonviolent Struggle for Justice

We're stuck up within the cycle of so-called "holy wars. " within the Jihad of Jesus, Dave Andrews argues that whereas this inter-communal clash is endemic, it isn't inevitable. reckoning on our knowing, our religions will be both a resource of escalating clash or a source for overcoming inter-communal clash; and for our religions to be a source for overcoming clash, we have to comprehend the center of all real faith as open-hearted compassionate spirituality.

Secularism and Identity: Non-Islamiosity in the Iranian Diaspora (Studies in Migration and Diaspora)

Inside of western political, media and educational discourses, Muslim groups are predominantly obvious during the prism in their Islamic religiosities, but there exist inside diasporic groups particular and complicated secularisms. Drawing on targeted interview and ethnographic fabric collected within the united kingdom, this e-book examines the ways that a kind of secularism - ’non-Islamiosity’ - among individuals of the Iranian diaspora shapes rules and practices of diasporic group and id, in addition to wider social relatives.

Entangled Pieties: Muslim-Christian Relations and Gendered Sociality in Java, Indonesia (Contemporary Anthropology of Religion)

This publication explores the social lifetime of Muslim ladies and Christian minorities amid Islamic and Christian routine in city Java, Indonesia. Drawing on anthropological views and 14 months of player remark among 2009 and 2013 within the multi-religious Javanese urban of Salatiga, this ethnography examines the interrelations among Islamic piety, Christian id, and gendered sociability in a time of a number of non secular revivals.

Extra resources for What's Wrong With What's Right -- A Critique of Imam Feisal Rauf's Book: What's Right With Islam

Sample text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.79 of 5 – based on 23 votes